Welcome to Phoenicia Pizza 28
Nestled in the heart of Phoenicia, NY, Phoenicia Pizza 28 stands out as a beloved local gem. With an inviting atmosphere and stunning views, it captivates both pizza aficionados and casual diners alike. Customers rave about their unique offerings, such as the signature "Phoenicia" Pie and the mouthwatering spinach pizza. The kitchen prides itself on using fresh ingredients and employs diverse baking techniques that elevate every dish. From flavorful grandma pizzas to fluffy garlic knots and crispy waffle fries, each bite is a delight. With friendly service and a loyalty program, this eatery promises a dining experience you'll eagerly return to.
Phoenicia Pizza 28: Reviews & Ratings
Definitely my favorite Pizza place! I love the spinach pizza . But every pie is great. So hard to choose when you’re standing there looking at all to choose from. The salads and wraps are fantastic and my favorite eggplant! Everyone is so welcoming such a nice atmosphere and the view is just incredible! I give this establishment a 5 in every area! I’ll be back !
Loved the “Phoenicia” Pie- the crust is amazing and this truly rivals some NYC/LI pizza joints we frequent. quick and friendly service. Great spot for hikers and skiers.
Our Top 5 pizzas from around the world (seriously) Third trip back to verify and yes, this place is awesome. Fresh ingredients and a combination of baking techniques that make for delicious pizza. Google won’t upload the entire length of our video review unfortunately but we love the positive welcoming staff as well. Strongly suggest a stopover for a slice (or 5) of this spot. A crew!
WOW! I feel like this pizza spot was transplanted from Brooklyn! Everything we ordered was stellar. The grandma pizza is one of the best I had, exploding with flavor Garlic knots are soft and chewy in the middle. Onteora hot hero with grilled chicken, mozzarella, pesto, pepper with perfectly toasted bread. Loaded waffle fries crispy. I'm shocked this amazing eatery is located in such a remote area. HIGHLY recommend!
This is some of the best pizza in the area. I grab a slice whenever I'm around and they are always so friendly and welcoming. They have a loyalty program, too! Go! You won't be disappointed.
We stopped by craving a couple slices and we’re thrilled to see their amazing selection of pizza & pin wheels. I had the grandma slice, which was a garlic pizza with chunky sauce on top. The crust was soft snd chewy under the sauce and crispy on the bottom. Pretty amazing. We also has a couple of broccoli pinwheels that we’re stuffed with ricotta, veggies & seasoning. Definitely worth a stop!!
This pizza is AMAZING! Great variety of flavors, each of which is delicious. Prices are also reasonable. We're so lucky to have this place! The other (wordy) review that unfavorably compares this place to another place further east on Rt 28 is laughable. My wife and I went to that other place once and quickly declared our allegiance to Pizza 28. There's no comparison.
Ok RUN don’t walk to this place!! Pizza was out of this world. The crust was crunchy and the varieties were amazing. Buffalo chicken pulled pork and ricotta toppings just to start. Garlic knots amazing and meatballs delicious! The help were so sweet and friendly. Family owned and operated!!! Can’t say enough great things about it
Location
-
5575 NY-28, Phoenicia, NY 12464, United States Hotline: +1 845-688-2033
Welcome to Phoenicia Pizza 28, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Phoenicia, New York! Located at 5575 NY-28, this delightful pizzeria has quickly become a beloved staple for locals and visitors alike. With a phone number of +1 845-688-2033, they are ready to take your orders and serve you in a warm, inviting atmosphere that has everyone raving.
As you step inside, you’ll be greeted by a welcoming team, eager to share their passion for pizza. The reviews speak volumes about the quality and taste of the offerings here. Customer Katherine Veitch describes Phoenicia Pizza 28 as her “favorite pizza place,” particularly raving about the spinach pizza and the wide selection that makes choosing a challenge. You’ll also find delectable salads and wraps that complement their pizza perfectly, making it an ideal spot for all tastes.
Food lovers have proclaimed the crust of the “Phoenicia” Pie to be amazing, with one customer even claiming it rivals offerings from New York City and Long Island. Whether you’re a hiker or a skier, this pizzeria is the perfect pit stop to refuel and recharge. The fresh ingredients and unique baking techniques elevate each bite, and you can't help but appreciate the care that goes into making every pie.
Cristol Show emphasizes that Phoenicia Pizza 28 deserves recognition for being part of their “Top 5 pizzas from around the world.” This speaks not only to the flavor but also to the passion that the staff brings to the dining experience. The restaurant is more than just a place to grab a slice—it’s a community hub where you can soak in breathtaking views while enjoying mouthwatering food.
Don’t miss out on their grandma pizza, which bursts with flavor and has left customers like Nona Chen in awe. From soft and chewy garlic knots to the crispy loaded waffle fries, each dish is crafted with love and attention to detail. Their Onteora hot hero is another must-try, with perfectly grilled chicken and a savory pesto, served on toast that's just right.
Phoenicia Pizza 28 is more than a restaurant; it’s a culinary adventure set within picturesque surroundings. If you’re in the area, or even if you’re not, this place should be on your list—your taste buds will thank you! With a loyalty program that rewards frequent visitors, you’ll find yourself returning for “slice after slice.” Experience for yourself why so many can’t stop talking about this incredible eatery. Go ahead, take that trip to Phoenicia and indulge in pizza perfection!